JenBen, I also used Roger and the Wiley books–also CPAExcel. Since this was my first exam, I can't compare Roger to anything but CPAExcel. For AUD, I felt pretty confident going in, but my second testlet was a killer and I bombed it, so I have no idea how I did overall. There was a fair amount of overlap in questions between Wiley & CPAExcel, since they all draw from the database of old AICPA released questions. Right now I'm preparing for BEC, and I see that CPA goes into more detail on some things that Roger just skimmed over…but Roger sure makes things a lot more easy to understand. He's definitely a good presenter.
Frankly, I'm *happy* for the continued wait for AUD scores. I really want to get through my first pass on the BEC study materials before then, since if I didn't pass, I'll get depressed and it will probably throw me off studying for BEC for a few days (scheduled to take BEC 10/3).