Salary Requirements Question

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #199145
    jm962011
    Participant

    I hate the salary requirements question!! I’m not desperate for a job, ok, MAYBE I am but I would consider any competitive offer, especially when you include benefits.

    Just got turned down for a phone interview because my range was too high. I don’t think I was necessarily shooting over the moon, either. I used Robert Half salary guides to help me estimate my range but I understand some companies don’t go by that. It’s honestly just frustrating.

Viewing 7 replies - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #752670
    mhueycpa
    Participant

    If you don't mind sharing your level of experience, location, and what range you requested?

    THE 300 CLUB WILL DO JUST FINE!

    #752671
    mhueycpa
    Participant

    If you don't mind sharing your level of experience, location, and what range you requested?

    THE 300 CLUB WILL DO JUST FINE!

    #752672
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Sometimes employers ask this question because they know that their pay will be low and want to only move forward with candidates who will consider the lower pay. For example, I work at a college in an area with a very low COL. The pay for most positions here is 1/2 of what it is at most colleges, and the pay for the position at most colleges is substantially less than the pay for the same position at most other types of businesses. So, for example, if someone is applying for a position that in the general American market would pay $100,000, but based on our region and the fact that we're a college we're only going to pay $40,000, we might as well found out at the start that they're not willing to work for less than $80,000, instead of flying them in for a 3-day interview process, then offering them $40,000 and having them walk out insulted. So, you may have run into a situation like that.

    However, I still avoid that question like the plague. I have never had a specific required salary, so I always answer evasively, something along the lines of “I'm sure we can work out compensation”, and if they push further, ask them what their range in for the position. I have never yet had to be the one to name a requirement first. I have seen people have to name their requirements first, but only when they've brought it up. (Ex: when I've been part of the interview process, we've generally not discussed salary at a first interview, and saved it to discuss with a top candidate or candidates only. So, if in a first interview a candidate brings it up, our response is usually “What would you require?” then “Yes, we can meet that” or “this probably won't be the right fit for you” depending on their response.) If they're the one bringing up salary, make them name a figure first. You have nothing to gain by naming a requirement – name something low and you tell them they can rip you off; name something high and they will do as they've done here and decide not to interview you.

    Sometimes the screeners or interviewers are persistent and you're stuck naming a figure, but most of the time (and thankfully so far in my experience) you can side-step it with a “I'm sure we can work something out; I'm sure you'll be fair; I'll be considering total compensation, so I'm sure we'll line up”; etc.

    Sorry to hear you lost out on the interview…but hopefully it's a case where they were going to low-ball you to the point that you wouldn't be interested anyway. 🙂

    #752673
    Pandarama
    Participant

    Maybe you should just make your salary requirement more realistic. Some companies really need to use that info you provide them more heavily than others.

    For example, last year my boss (teenie tiny firm) needed to hire someone. He knew he couldn't afford to bring on someone that had a ton of good experience because he wouldn't be able to afford them despite him needing someone who had at least some sort of experience.

    Anytime there is a request for salary requirement, try your best not to put a number in there. Hopefully the form will allow you to enter a few words instead of numbers. Because every firm offers different benefits, it's difficult to place a number in the salary requirement field. If you are able to type words, then just simply say “may vary based on benefits offered”.

    A coworker was debating on applying for jobs elsewhere, thinking they would get a larger salary. They were too caught up in thinking about how a friend said they make $60k a year while my coworker is making $55k a year. What they didn't consider was the benefits the other person was receiving compared to their own. For example, their friend has to contribute towards health insurance premiums but my company pays for single coverage in full for you.

    BEC - 80
    AUD - 64, 75 - credit lost, 90!!
    REG - 73, 74, 83
    FAR - 61, 72, 85

    Feels good finishing on my best note. Time to watch the mailbox.

    #752674
    jm962011
    Participant

    In the midwest, I started at 43k right out of college in corporate tax for a software company. Then I moved to a Fortune 50 that started at $50k with a 7.5% annual bonus, also doing corporate tax. I am currently (although tomorrow is my last day as I am moving out east) at $60k, also in corporate tax. I just became a licensed CPA. For this area, I think $60k is a little over and I think Staff Accountants would be lucky to make $55k. I think an entry level auditor or tax associate at Big 4 will make about $55k starting out.

    But, I am moving out to the Boston area so the COL is larger than the midwest. I've kind of been applying all over the place because I do want more than tax experience. This was for a staff accountant position in the hospitality industry and I said my range was $58k – $63k. I currently have a conditional offer with Robert Half out of Providence for $58k, but it is conditional on them finding placement for me. It would be with their Salaried Professional group which is “long term temp work.”

    I think I just low balled myself for a Senior Tax role closer to Boston. I said $65k but I think they'd be willing to go up to $75k. Honestly, its not even so much about the money anymore. I would go back to the $50k job because the work/life balance was amazing.

    Once I get out there and see just how far Boston is with the traffic, I might consider some experienced Big 4 positions. At this point, I'm worried my commute is going to 90 minutes each way :-/

    #752675
    jm962011
    Participant

    Yes, when I actually get to the phone screen and they ask, I also say I want to consider the full compensation package, including benefits. That is VERY VERY VERY important to me.. 401k match, how much insurance is/what I have to pay, etc. I also think it is important to consider the amount of hours you're working.

    #752676
    Missy
    Participant

    I'm not sure about other states, but the “Boston Area” really is only about a dozen or so zip codes. The further you move from those zip codes, the lower the salaries. A staff accountant in downtown Boston just might make 70k. Go north about 20 miles,less chance they'd make above 60. Theres a huge difference when it comes to hospitals as well, just because Mass General would pay 70k doesn't mean “Anna Jacques” hospital would even pay 50.

    Also keep in mind that when a job is listed they already know what they are going to pay. So if its a listing for a staff accountant with a bachelors degree required, they aren't inclined to bump it up because someone with higher credentials applies.

    Never give a range, even. Its a loaded question. What if you said you were looking for 63 and they were perfectly prepared to offer 75?

    Licensed Massachusetts Non Reporting CPA since 2012
    Finance/Admin/HR Manager

Viewing 7 replies - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • The topic ‘Salary Requirements Question’ is closed to new replies.