Here's another conflict between Gleim and Ninja:
On March 1, Green went to Easy Car Sales to buy a car. Green spoke to a salesperson and agreed to buy a car that Easy had in its showroom. On March 5, Green made a $500 down payment and signed a security agreement to secure the payment of the balance of the purchase price. On March 10, Green picked up the car. On March 15, Easy filed the security agreement. On what date did Easy’s security interest attach?
Ninja says: Correct: B March 5
Before a security interest attaches, there must be a security agreement (oral or written) between the debtor and the secured party, the secured party must give value, and the debtor must have rights in the collateral. Green gave value ($500) and signed a security agreement on March 5.
Gleim says it's March 10. I agree with Gleim because, as Ninja states, the secured party must give value. Yet it explains that Green gave value. Green is the debtor, not the secured party. Easy gives value on March 10, when Green picks up the car. Anyone agree or disagree with me? These questions are so confusing!