Here is the question….
Question: 3 On December 1, Wall Company purchased trading securities. Pertinent data are as follows:
Security. Cost Fair value at 12/31
A. 39,000. 36,000
B. 50,000. 55,000
C. 96,000. 85,000
On December 31, Wall reclassified its investment in security C from trading to available-for-sale because Wall intends to retain security C. What net loss on its securities should be included in Wall’s income statement for the year ended December 31?
A. $11,000
B. $14,000
C. $0
D. $9,000
Answer (D) is correct.
Unrealized holding gains and losses on trading securities are included in earnings, and reclassification is at fair value. Furthermore, “for a security transferred from the trading category, the unrealized holding gain or loss at the date of transfer already will have been recognized in earnings and shall not be reversed.†Thus, the net unrealized holding loss at 12/31 is $9,000 ($3,000 loss on A – $5,000 gain on B + $11,000 loss on C).
My issue with this question, is that we don't analyze anything until 12/31 of the first year, which this is. At that time we made the change from trading to available for sale (Security C), but NOTHING has been placed into earnings before now. The answer is worded such, that we've already taken care of any unrealized losses in earnings, when in reality we have not yet.
BEC (2/28/16) ----- 78
FAR (09/10/16)-----
AUD
REG
CIA, CGAP, CFE